Quality Assessment of OpenStreetMap's Points of Interest with Large-Scale Real Data

OpenStreetMap (OSM) data are geographical data that are easy and open to access and therefore used for a large set of applications including travel demand modelling. However, often there is a limited awareness about the shortcomings of Volunteered Geographic Information (VGI) data, such as OSM. One important issue for the application in travel demand modelling is the completeness of OSM elements, respectively Points of Interest (POI), since it directly influences the predictions of trip distributions. This might cause unreliable model sensitivities and end up in wrong predictions leading to expensive misinterpretations of the effects of policy measures. Due to a lack of large scale real-world data, a detailed assessment of the quality of POI from OSM has not been done yet. Hence, in this work, we assess the quality of POI from OSM for the use within travel demand models using surveyed real-world data from 49 areas in Germany. We perform a descriptive and a model-based analysis using spatial, demographic and intrinsic indicators for two common trip purpose categories used in travel demand modelling. We show that the completeness of POI data in OSM depends on the category of POI. ... mehrWe further show that intrinsic indicators and indicators calculated based on data from other sources (e.g., land use or census data) are able to detect quality deficiencies of OSM data.