Wherever futures are addressed in research, scientists claim that their inquiry should be anticipatory, inclusive, accountable, and relevant to those outside the sciences. Accordingly, many scientific projects, and in particular technology assessment (TA), draw on methods such as scenario building, narrative, and discourse analysis as a pattern for interpreting ongoing projects and shaping future trajectories in line with this idea of social relevance.
TA is conceptually committed to anticipation, inclusivity, and complexity management (Grunwald 2019). For example, vision assessment (VA) analyses discourses around socio-technical visions to reveal social dynamics (Frey et al. 2022) and narratives to trace motifs and discursive shifts (Dobroć et al. 2023), building scenarios that make them visible and enable discussion of possible futures (Schneider et al. 2022). Such practice requires reflexivity, including reflection on different audiences and publics, such as society, science, or TA itself, which seeks to reflect on its practice. It is recognized that TA becomes an actor in different contexts, e.g., future-making, as it actively engages with societal change, having emerged from parliamentary advice (Schneider/Lösch 2015). ... mehr
Our paper focuses on questions about the objects and subjects of TA research, its addressees and agents: for whom are participatory methods of TA, and who participates? How, if at all, do these analyses and results emerge from science? What, if anything, makes them assessable and relevant to those they are intended to reach? We reflect on the 'futuristic' practices of TA around two different projects (3D print/viable city).
Dobroć, P., Bögel, P., & Upham, P. (2023). Narratives of change: Strategies for inclusivity in shaping socio-technical future visions. Futures, 145, 103076.
Frey, P., Dobroć, P., Hausstein, A., Heil, R., Lösch, A., Roßmann, M., & Schneider, C. (2022). Vision Assessment: Theoretische Reflexionen zur Erforschung soziotechnischer Zukünfte (p. 180). KIT Scientific Publishing.
Schneider C, Lösch A. (2015) What About Your Futures, Technology Assessment? An Essay on How to Take the Visions of TA Serious Seriously, TATuP.)