Isotopic labeling of nanoparticles for the evaluation of their environmental fate in mesocosm experiments

Mesocosm systems simulating floodplain areas are essential for the understanding of the environmental fate and effects of engineered nanoparticles (ENPs). In such mesocosm studies, the quantification of different types of nanoparticles coexisting in natural systems and containing the same element is often challenging. Such coexistence is expected e.g., for ENPs simultaneously released into the environmental systems. Despite the relevance of the coexistence, little is known about combined behavior and effects of ENPs in the environment. In this study, we developed a method for the quantification and differentiation of silver nanoparticles enriched by $^{109}$Ag isotope ($^{109}$Ag-NPs) and sulfidized silver nanoparticles with natural isotopic distribution (S-Ag-NPs) in water, soil, and sediment and applied it to evaluate the environmental fate of these nanoparticles introduced simultaneously together with gold (Au-NPs) and titanium dioxide (TiO$_2$-NPs) nanoparticles into mesocosms simulating an aquatic-terrestrial transition zone. High nanoparticle recoveries determined in water, sand, and soil spiked with nanoparticle mixtures indicate that the application of isotopically enriched ENPs will allow their differentiation from other nanoparticles containing the same element in environmental compartments even at the concentrations in the range of natural background. ... mehrThe co-accumulation of $^{109}$Ag-NPs, S-Ag-NPs, and Au-NPs in the top layer of sediment and soil and in biofilms observed in mesocosm studies suggests that these compartments can act as effective sinks for these ENPs. We suggest that the hetero-aggregation between different co-occurring ENPs and their high affinity to biota are major mechanisms controlling their fate in the aquatic-terrestrial transition zone. A high co-enrichment of $^{109}$Ag-NPs, S-Ag-NPs, Au-NPs, and TiO$_{2}$-NPs in/on algae, biofilms, leaves, and amphipods suggests an enhanced risk of biomagnification. The findings of this study will contribute to a better understanding of the fate of ENPs and their combined effects in environmental compartments, where the simultaneous presence of diverse nanoparticles is expected.