VisNec: Measuring and Leveraging Visual Necessity for Multimodal Instruction Tuning

The effectiveness of multimodal instruction tuning depends not only on dataset scale, but also critically on whether training samples genuinely require visual reasoning. However, existing instruction datasets often contain a substantial portion of visually redundant samples (solvable from text alone), as well as multimodally misaligned supervision that can degrade learning. To address this, we propose VisNec (Visual Necessity Score), a principled data selection framework that measures the marginal contribution of visual input during instruction tuning. By comparing predictive loss with and without visual context, VisNec identifies whether a training instance is vision-critical, redundant, or misaligned. To preserve task diversity, we combine VisNec with semantic clustering and select high-necessity samples within each cluster. Across 10 downstream benchmarks, training on only 15% of the LLaVA-665K dataset selected by VisNec achieves 100.2% of full-data performance. On the smaller Vision-Flan-186K dataset, our selection not only further reduces data size but surpasses full-data training by 15.8%. These results demonstrate that measuring and leveraging visual necessity provides an effective solution for both efficient and robust multimodal instruction tuning. ... mehrProject Page: https://dmk041218.github.io/VisNec/.