KIT | KIT-Bibliothek | Impressum | Datenschutz

Non-Identity and Compensation for Climate Change: The Not-So-Minor Difference Claim

Düvel, Eike ORCID iD icon 1; García-Portela, Laura
1 Institut für Technikfolgenabschätzung und Systemanalyse (ITAS), Karlsruher Institut für Technologie (KIT)

Abstract:

This paper examines the implications of the Non-Identity Problem (NIP) for real-world climate change-related duties, responding to Lukas Tank’s Minor Difference Claim. Tank argues that robust climate action (involving mitigation, adaptation, and compensation) is already required to respond to the foreseeable negative effects on individuals whose identities are fixed, so accepting (or “biting the bullet” on) the NIP makes only a minor difference to our climate change-related duties. We challenge this view by arguing that accepting the NIP makes a not-so-minor difference for compensatory climate duties. First, it affects their extent. Second, it generates highly unequal compensatory claims both across individuals born at different times (intragenerational difference) and among those exposed to the same climate impacts at different times (intertemporal difference). We conclude that one must either accept these implications or develop a strategy to resolve or avoid the NIP.


Verlagsausgabe §
DOI: 10.5445/IR/1000199152
Veröffentlicht am 16.11.2026
Originalveröffentlichung
DOI: 10.1017/S0953820826100612
Cover der Publikation
Zugehörige Institution(en) am KIT Institut für Technikfolgenabschätzung und Systemanalyse (ITAS)
Publikationstyp Zeitschriftenaufsatz
Publikationsjahr 2026
Sprache Englisch
Identifikator ISSN: 0953-8208, 1741-6183
KITopen-ID: 1000199152
Erschienen in Utilitas
Verlag Cambridge University Press (CUP)
Vorab online veröffentlicht am 13.11.2026
Schlagwörter Non-Identity Problem; climate ethics; intergenerational justice; compensation duties
Nachgewiesen in OpenAlex
KIT – Die Universität in der Helmholtz-Gemeinschaft
KITopen Landing Page