Evaluation of Different Manual Placement Strategies to Ensure Uniformity of the V-FPGA

Virtual FPGA (V-FPGA) architectures are useful as both early prototyping testbeds for custom FPGA architectures, as well as to enable advanced features which may not be available on a given host FPGA. V-FPGAs use standard FPGA synthesis and placement tools, and as a result the maximum application frequency is largely determined by the synthesis of the V-FPGA onto the host FPGA. Minimal net delays in the virtual layer are crucial for applications, but due to increased routing congestion, these delays are often significantly worse for larger than for smaller designs. To counter this effect, we investigate three different placement strategies with varying amounts of manual intervention. Taking the regularity of the V-FPGA architecture into account, a regular placement of tiles can lead to an 37% improvement in the achievable clock frequency. In addition, uniformity of the measured net delays is increased by 39%, which makes implementation of user applications more reproducible. As a trade-off, these manual placement strategies increase area usage of the virtual layer up to 16%.